Discussion about Appropriation of Images

As we have discussed the difference between copy and creation for the appropriation work earlier, if an appropriation is considered as only copying and derivation, then this work must be just simply copy the elements from the original one such as its image, style, or similar ideas; and for the creating, it is necessary to change many things from the original work, not simply the appearance like the image and style, but also create a new meaning which is to subvert its original meaning and has a strong distinction. With this idea which is agreed by most in this class, we looked at the image “Mrs. Richard Yates” which is an original work by Gilbert Stuart. The subject in this painting is a noble madam sitting with an elegant posture. However, her expression is bored, disdainful, and superior, which creates a distance from audience. Then the other image is the appropriated work by Rodney Pike, he used the iconic of Mr. Bean to replace the distant face of Mrs. Richard. This created a striking contrast that Mr. Bean is characterized with humorous and funny, it gave audiences the friendly feeling and relaxing which subverted the original meaning. I think this gives a good example to understand the difference between creation and copying in appropriated work.